How Mouthwashing’s Circular Structure Develops Blame and Criticism

S.K. Stewart

Oct 23, 2026

In fall 2024, an indie game entitled Mouthwashing released into the video game ecosystem. With a mix of colorful nostalgia, sci-fi, and body horror, Mouthwashing is considered a psychological horror game in which a player must navigate a crisis following a cargo ship crash. As the game progresses, the player experiences multiple lines of narrative, one pre-crash and one post-crash. These frames of narrative are interspersed, moving at once towards and away from the moment the cargo ship makes impact, and it becomes clear quickly that things aboard the ship aren’t exactly what they seem. The game seems intent on exploring the concept of blame, particularly emphasized in its gameplay being littered with the phrase “take accountability.” As a horror fanatic and writer, I found it useful to consider the employment of a circular narrative in order to place blame. This marriage of structure and meaning seemed familiar and ultimately reminded me of William Faulkner’s novel The Sound and the Fury, a traditional text of the Southern Gothic which develops a similarly fragmented structure, nonlinear temporality, and focus on blame and responsibility as Mouthwashing. Ultimately, it seems that the horror genre shares this fundamental relationship between circular narrative and blame across mediums.

The game itself opens with an unnamed character aboard the PonyExpress, an interplanetary cargo shipping company, facilitating the crash of the ship into a meteor. The gameplay is most comparable to a playable novel which is important to note here as this line of action, and all narratives contained in the game, does not provide the player with a choice. The story unfolds without much input from the player beyond physically moving characters through space. After the crash, we learn that the captain, Curly, has been maimed beyond reason, incapable of speech or movement. The remaining crew members are trapped in space with a damaged ship and quickly dwindling resources. It should be noted that, due to the company’s decision to add a crew member last minute, the resources were already insufficient for the journey. This scene, immediately after the crash, allows us to meet the characters for the first time. For all of the time post-crash, the player character is Jimmy, the current captain of the crew due to the previous captain’s physical impairment. We, as Jimmy, speak with Anya, the crew nurse; Swansea, the ship’s mechanic; and Daisuke, Swansea’s mentee and aforementioned last-minute addition. Each of these characters will face immense suffering throughout the game.

The story is revealed through two separate perspectives, Captain Curly before the crash and Captain Jimmy after the crash. These two perspectives are interlaced, switching back and forth through time as Curly’s vignettes creep closer to the day of the crash while Jimmy’s show the ever-worsening situation on the ship. These moments where the player switches between Curly and Jimmy are visualized through glitching graphics and the haunting phrases “I hope this hurts” and “take accountability” flashing intermittently.

The basic order of events is as such: Jimmy assaults and impregnates Anya, Anya tells Curly, and Jimmy becomes antsy and suspicious of what’s waiting for him when the crew arrives at their destination. Jimmy, co-captain at the time, chooses to direct the ship into a meteor, deciding it is better to take everyone down with him than face retribution for his treatment of Anya. Curly attempts to course correct and is maimed in the impact. The rest of the crew survives the crash, and Jimmy allows blame to fall on Curly since he is now incapable of exposing Jimmy, mute and immobile as he is. Jimmy’s time as captain is disastrous, culminating in Anya locking herself in the med-bay to commit suicide rather than continue starving, taking abuse from Jimmy, and gestating a fetus that is the result of sexual violence. Jimmy attempts to send the youngest crew member, the last-minute addition, through the vents into the nurse’s station despite the knowledge that the vent has been unsafe for many transport missions. Daisuke still attempts to crawl through the vent, severely injuring himself in the process. Anya is already dead by the time the med-bay door is unlocked. Daisuke will be the next to die from the injuries he sustained. Swansea, the mechanic aboard the ship, turns on Jimmy, antagonizing him with the knowledge that Anya told him what Jimmy had done and that Jimmy was generally unfit to lead in a crisis. Eventually, Jimmy will kill Swansea as well.

All of this is interspersed with Curly’s memories of the time before the crash, the recognition that he knew something was wrong on board but did not act. By the end of the game, Curly is the only member of the crew still alive, left in an inhumane state alone in one of the ship’s cryogenic emergency pods. Jimmy ends his life offscreen after placing Curly into the emergency pod. He has, to his belief, taken responsibility. As a player goes through the game in its entirety, they will also see posters from the company PonyExpress which detail inhumane labor practices, wage theft, and collective punishment. It is a draconian company representative of the worst late-stage capitalism has to offer. So, who is to blame?

This is, in part, why I drew a connection between Mouthwashing and The Sound and the Fury. Beyond the shared circular narrative structure and emphasis on blame, it is clear that structure and meaning meet so neatly in these stories because there are spheres of blame surrounding the events.

The novel approaches time in a very similar nonlinear fashion. We move forwards and backwards in time and see the Compson family from many different perspectives, all of which circle around and enshroud the horrible truth at its center. We learn through a story of death, suicide, and incest that Benjy, a mentally disabled man in this family of secrets and contempt, has been castrated following an attempted assault on a young woman. It is unclear how much Benjy understood what he was doing as inappropriate or, in truth, what actually happened between him and the girl. The outrage is enough, however, to have him castrated and further isolated from public spaces. Once again, the nonlinear construction of the story seems to ask: who is to blame?

For Mouthwashing, we can just as easily condemn Jimmy for his violence as PonyExpress for their negligent practices or Curly for his lack of direct action. This doesn’t mean that any one party is the “correct” villain but instead that they are all actively blamed concurrently. The same can be said of the Compson family. We see a family in decay. Their fundamental status in the world has changed, and through the nonlinear temporality and imperfect perspectives of each character, we see the complex power structures of poverty, white supremacy, and family. Each character has their own individual blame to carry, but they are also acted upon by systems beyond their power and by each other’s mistakes. The circular structure allows for a deconstructed experience of events. That is to say, we have the opportunity to see that same event, or series of events, through different perspectives at different times. With this plethora of perspective lenses, a fuller picture appears that allows not simply condemnation for poor character but a critique of the systems which functionally divide, disadvantage, and destroy us.

S.K. Stewart is an MFA student at the University of New Mexico where she currently serves as an instructor and reader for Blue Mesa Review. As a mixed-race woman and southern lesbian, she makes it a point in her writing to give voice to those silenced by the monolith of the Lost Cause South.

Jess and I: An Ode to Stone Butch Blues

You likely won’t find Leslie Feinberg’s novel Stone Butch Blues in a bookstore, but it is worth the eye strain from the version on Internet Archives or the cost to print out a paper copy. Published in 1993, Stone Butch Blues tells the life of Jess Goldberg, a stone...

Ye Olde Modern Times

“What do the Middle Ages have to do with me?” asked a student on the first day of my medieval literature class.  With a cognizant sigh and a slick smile, my professor replied, “A lot more than you think.”  I sat fidgeting in my swivel chair, trying to digest the...

Roadrunner and text that reads "Best of Net"

2027 Best of the Net Nominees

Congratulations and best of luck to our 2027 Best of the Net Nominees! "Spitfire" by Casey Reiland "Her English" by Jose Oseguera "Horse Girl" by Kaila Lancaster